Community Health Worker Coaching, Food Insecurity, and Physical Activity in the Healthy Food First Trial: A Causal Mediation and Longitudinal Analysis

Top Things to Know

FIM programs seeking to influence multiple cardiometabolic behaviors may need to address physical activity directly.

The findings suggest more intensive approaches, such as behavioral reinforcement, supervised physical activity, digital self-monitoring or text-based coaching, may be needed alongside FIM interventions.

Future studies should prospectively track CHW coaching dose, content and adherence to determine which components influence behavior.

Summary of Conclusion/Findings

This secondary analysis of the Healthy Food First randomized clinical trial examined whether community health worker (CHW) lifestyle coaching increased physical activity among adults with hypertension and food insecurity and whether changes in food insecurity mediated that effect. Among 338 participants with complete food insecurity and physical activity data, 259 were included in fully adjusted analyses; food insecurity improved overall from baseline to 12 months, but CHW assignment was not associated with change in food insecurity or physical activity. At 12 months, there was little evidence of an indirect effect through changes in food insecurity (16.2 MET-min/week; 95% CI, −62.7 to 121.8) or a direct effect of CHW coaching (−214.1 MET-min/week; 95% CI, −871.7 to 484.5), and the proportion mediated was near zero. Longitudinal analyses similarly found no significant association between CHW coaching and total physical activity across 12 and 18 months (B=363.7 MET-min/week; SE=302.8; P=0.23), with no evidence that the association differed over time. The findings suggest that modest improvements in food insecurity combined with monthly CHW coaching were insufficient to meaningfully change physical activity, although interpretation is limited by self-reported physical activity, no baseline physical activity measurement, modest changes in food insecurity, limited physical activity-specific coaching and declining participation in CHW sessions.