Is that Hospital Food Pantry an Illegal Patient Inducement? Analysis of Health Care Fraud Laws as Barriers to Food and Nutrition Security Interventions.
Top Things to Know
The study explores how health care fraud and abuse laws act as barriers to food and nutrition security interventions in health care settings. The Anti-Kickback Statute (AKS) and Civil Monetary Penalties Law (CMPL) restrict health care providers from offering free or discounted food to Medicare and Medicaid beneficiaries due to concerns about inducing patient loyalty or unnecessary health care utilization. Health care organizations often limit or abandon food security programs due to legal uncertainties, administrative burdens, and compliance costs.
ExistinglLegal safeguards are insufficient and create inequities. Some “safe harbor” provisions allow food programs under strict conditions, but these exemptions are narrowly applied and inconsistently enforced. Well-resourced hospitals can navigate legal complexities, while smaller or rural providers face greater compliance risks, worsening health disparities.
Policy reform is needed to expand food is medicine programs. Recent Medicare and Medicaid demonstrations in states like Massachusetts and North Carolina show promise for integrating food benefits into health coverage. Expanding safe harbor protections, creating reimbursement pathways, and clarifying federal regulations could help scale food interventions without legal risks.
Summary of Conclusion/Findings
This paper highlights how federal fraud and abuse laws act as significant barriers to implementing food and nutrition security interventions in clinical settings. While intended to prevent misuse of health care funds, these laws often restrict innovative programs that improve patient health and reduce health care costs. Policy reforms are needed to provide clearer guidelines, expand exemptions, and integrate food-based interventions into standard health care benefits. Without legal changes, many hospitals and health centers will remain hesitant to offer food assistance, limiting access for vulnerable populations who would benefit most.